Meat CSA – Butcherbox – First Month

I’ve been missing the challenge of cooking with (almost) only what’s provided in a CSA box each month/week, and have decided to join a meat CSA + a salad CSA this year.

The meat CSA is monthly with no commitment, and the salad CSA will run from June – October.

ButcherBox is the meat source I’ve chosen for at least these first few months of Spring/Summer – I have another in mind that’s more of a 3-month commitment, but juuuust missed the quarterly cutoff date for signup.

ButcherBox offers a selection of meat from 100% grass fed/grass finished cows, pastured chickens, and antibiotic and hormone-free pigs that have led presumably happy lives. Each standard box features 8 – 11 pounds of meat and costs $129 with free shipping. According to ButcherBox, this equals out to 18 – 25 meals of 6 – 8 ounce portions for just under $6.00 per meal. They also offer larger box, but since I have a family of 2, I think the smaller will do.

They also have a promotion going on for a free pack of sugar-free bacon with your first box. And, they’re also heavily promoting with promo codes right now. If you sign up using this link:, you get $10 off your first box and I get referral bucks for sharing the love.

On to the box!

The shipment came in a sturdy cardboard box with heavy wrapping and dry ice. All items were loaded into the nice freezer bag you see, and my apartment building actually didn’t notify me on time of the delivery – so mine sat in the mail room for 24 hours before I could get to it … and the meat was still frozen. Color me impressed.


The Haul

(2) packages ground beef (2 lbs. total – estimated 8 servings)

(3) packages chicken breast tenders (2.5 lbs. total – estimated 10 servings)

(2) sirloin steaks (1.5 lbs. total – estimated 6 servings)

(2) packages ranch steaks (1.06 lbs. total – estimated 4 servings)

(2) packages country style pork (2 lbs. total – estimated 8 servings)

1 bonus package sugar-free bacon (10 ounces or 11 slices – “free” meat)

I based my serving estimates on 4 ounces per person. If everything goes according to that (admittedly ambitious) plan, I should have 36 servings of meat. With a family of 2, that should make 18 meals – or 4.5 weeks of dinner if we eat 4 home cooked meals a week. Since I generally only spend about $100 on groceries per week, $129 for a months’ worth of at least dinner meat seems like great savings – especially when you calculate in the cost of great quality meat when purchased somewhere like Whole Foods. That ish is prohibitively expensive.


The Meals

The first thing I made was Nom Nom Paleo’s Kaluah Pork in the Instant Pot with all of the pork. I wanted a big hunk of meat I could grab at will over the next week (turned into 2) because I was going to be extra busy and wouldn’t be cooking regular dinners. I also used a few slices of the bacon here and baked the rest up so I’d have snacking bacon + some yummy bacon grease to cook with.

The “Country Style Pork” was really chunks of what appeared to be shoulder cut into hunks that looked to be either nice chop or something else sized. When faced with unspecified pork, I did what I always do – went low and slow (or in this case, faked low and slow with machinery).

The pork made 8 servings: 4 dinners (2 pork and pineapple fried rice, 2 pork & cabbage), and 4 lunches (pork & kale salad with pineapple, pork & cabbage with an egg, pork tacos).

I noticed with the pork the recipe I made tasted a little better than usual. This method of pork cookery is not my absolute favorite, but was the one I trusted more in a pressure cooker, since I’m not terribly comfortable with the ratios and times for that piece of machinery yet.

The sirloin steak made 2 servings: I only got 1 dinner out of the sirloin steak because I didn’t have the heart to break up a steak into smaller components – it just felt like sacrilege.

I had intentions of marinating the steak and doing something schmancy, but just ended up pan frying them with the bare minimum of seasoning to eat with some leftover cabbage and butter. So much for the chimichurri I was craving.

The steak was fantastic, and I’m so happy I didn’t attempt to split it up into smaller meals. I know I said 6 meals up above, but that’s just crazy talk and I suspect my math is terrible. I could have maaaaaybe split it into 4 portions for two 2-serving meals, but damn that would have been sad. So, 1 happy meal it was – even with an uninspired fridge cleaner side.

I grabbed 1 of the 3 blocks of chicken tenders and roasted them tossed in a bit of ranch seasoning with veggies.

The chicken was great – maybe it’s psychosomatic, but I really think the chicken was moister – even though the tenders were thin strips, and I baked them aggressively (400F for 30 minutes). They weren’t entirely rubbery on reheat, either. I got 2 dinners + 1 lunch out of the block.

The second block of chicken was turned into my favorite low carb “crack” chicken. It was hard not eating the whole pan in one serving, but I managed to behave myself to get the three anticipated servings. (2 dinner + 1 lunch)

The third block of chicken I did a Thai-inspired kefir marinade on and cooked off to have on hand for lunches (3 servings).

The chicken made 9 servings: Each serving was 3-4 tenders or roughly 4 ounces.

I made simple steaks out of one package of ranch steak – just broiled quickly with a little butternut squash on the side.

The ranch steak made 2 servings with 2 servings left over for next month.


Actual Servings Garnered From This Box

8 servings pork

2 servings sirloin steak

9 servings chicken

A few servings bacon – mostly just incidental snack bacon

4 servings ranch steak (2 servings eaten, 2 left over)

Both pounds of ground beef (8 servings) are left over

31 total servings meat out of roughly 23 lunches and 19 dinners I usually make a month (When we’re behaving, we eat about 71 servings of meat a month at home between the two of us – I make 4 dinners for 2 a week, and I eat between 4 and 5 lunches at home; the DH eats 2 – 3 lunches at home per week). Some months are more; some are less – depending upon our schedules. This month featured more meals out than is ideal – but, I didn’t buy any meat this month at the store outside my ButcherBox, and I have lots of leftover meat – so there’s that.

So .. is this saving me money?


I estimate that I spend roughly a third to half my weekly food budget on meat – so about $30 – $50, and that meat is generally a mix of “good” stuff and “regular” stuff – just depends on the store I go to – but realistically, we’re usually only buying grass fed ground beef. The rest is whatever Trader Joe’s or the store we’re at has on hand. Unless it’s a Whole Foods week, then I just buy less meat because $$$$$ shock.

With what we spent at ButcherBox for the quality of meat we got – I think we saved money? I’ll have to give it a few more months to see if we actually did, but this month has at least provided us with the assurance that we have great quality meat in the freezer on hand for whenever we need it. If nothing else, that’s worth something – especially since I didn’t have to schlep all the way to Whole Foods and be aggravated about the ratio of #1 and #2 to #4 and #5 meat available. I also avoided the trap I fall into of either just buying the cheapest “good” stuff available and dealing with the consequences to my menu planning or grabbing an overpriced hunk of something because the energy expended in rapidly changing plans 57 times in the span of minutes because WF doesn’t have what I want has exhausted me to no end.





Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s